Sometimes I feel like I’m beating a dead horse here, but every time I turn around, I’m seeing the same mistakes surfacing again and again. Now, I realize that this is a taboo topic, but somebody needs to address it, so damnit, I will.
That’s right. We’re back on education again. It’s time to pull your heads out of the sand and take a long, hard look at what’s going on, and until you do, I will continue to pound you with the cold truth of the matter.
Of course, the overarching target of my contempt on this topic is the out of control education spending, which instead of getting better, just continues to get worse.
So what’s the big deal? Well, Monday saw the passing by the state senate of a $498 million increase to school spending, Then on Thursday, another bill went to the senate to increase school spending by another $1.1 billion over the next four years. This new bill also includes a roughly $900 million income tax increase over the next two years.
So what does Tarryl Clark (DFL), the senate assistant majority leader say about this tax increase?
“There is no such thing as a free lunch. To make these kinds of strategic investments, we need money.”
No shit. But what none of these people are considering is if this is a legitimate investment or not.
Now I’m not saying that schools don’t need funding… But I am saying that maybe, just maybe, there is some serious overspending going on. I mean, everybody is always so critical of government waste and overspending… But who’s holding the schools accountable for their money? Who’s going in and looking at the schools, and auditing their spending and cutting their waste? Nobody! And why not? Because it’s school, and it’s bad karma to mess with school. I mean, it’s the kids! Our future! How can you take anything away from the kids?
In short, I say that we take away the gluttonous bureaucracy that controls the system. Somebody is screwing something up here, and throwing more money into it will not help it, although the opportunity for more harm to be done is massive. Don’t believe me? I have the numbers right here.
In 2004-2005, the state spent 42.1% of the general fund budget on E-12 education. That’s $11.76 billion dollars out of $27.96 billion spent. That is the top state expenditure. In comparison, criminal justice received 5.2%, or $1.44 billion out of the total. 2006-2007 e-12 education will see $13.39 billion out of the general fund. Criminal justice will get $1.71 billion.
So what I would like to know is this… Where is all of this money going? By the number, between 1997 and 2007, Minnesota k-12 school enrollment rose only .27%, from 838,336 to 840,565 students. In the past 5 years, enrollment dropped .75%, from 846,891 to 840,565 students. But when we look at the money involved, the 2002-2003 budget gave k-12 $8.759 billion and the 1997-1998 budget was $5.733 billion. So if we put this all together, we get:
- Over the past 5 years, school enrollment dropped .75%, but the budget increased by 34.59%
- Over the past 10 years, school enrollment rose .27%, but the budget increased by 57.18%
And if you’re thinking that this number just reflects inflation, you’re wrong. 1997-2007 inflation rate was 27.23%. 2002-2007 was 14.29%.
So where is all of this money going? This is not the price of educating our children. This is something else entirely. This is the price of a bloated system that is not held accountable for its money expenditures. Why is it that when gas prices move, everybody jumps up and starts investigating price gouging and going after the oil companies, but when education spending grows, everybody nods in approval and accepts it as “the price of education”?
This is just silly, folks. And what’s worse is that with all of this data at hand, the state legislators, backed heavily by the education unions and lobying groups, is working to increase education spending even more at the continued expense of the taxpayers via increased income taxes.
I know it’s been said before, most notably by Ronald Reagan, but something that needs to be said now, more than ever, is that the problem right now isn’t a matter of taxes that are too low, the problem is that government spending is too high. With 42.1% of state spending being tossed down the hole of k-12 education, I think it’s time to put education under the microscope and under the gun to try to reign in their uncontrolled spending.